The other day we finally got to move our Religion section (and by we I mean another girl and I due to some well timed exits by the rest of my coworkers), a cause for much celebration. Previously the section had resulted had caused contention between all of us due not to differing religious beliefs, but because it was packed so tight that none of us could move the books. Even those of us with small fingers were powerless against the towering wall of spines. We tried sending books back, only to have them return in larger quantities (“Hey, it’s Easter,” the company thought, “You need these books.”). We tried creating a separate backstock for the titles, but staring at if for long periods a time had the ability to induce tears. Shelving at all became a battle where we would pull two books to make room for one, never mind that all the titles had been stocked down the absolute minimum out of necessity.
It was no way to run a section, and we knew that, but at the time we had no alternatives. With the move, however, the section expanded from a three foot to a four foot gondola and gained a second gondola specifically for Christian fiction. Suddenly where there had once been backstock, there was now empty space thanks to the added room. Sure, we didn’t need to put out all ten copies of C.S. Lewis’s The Problem of Pain—one could ask why our store needed that many copies to begin with—but we had the room, so why not! There were face-outs even, despite the Da Vinci Code tie-in madness that resulted in even more religious titles than before.
Oh Happiness. Oh Glorious Day! We could shelve without losing fingers. We could actually alphabetize the section rather than just shoving the books in and running.
(Insert allusion to Holy Light or great weight lifted here)
Of course now that we had a Christian fiction section we had to weed the appropriate books out of regular fiction. It was due to overwhelming customer request that it had been created at all, and we couldn’t have it looking bare and neglected. There was no way to pull up a comprehensive list of the books in our store due to an inventory glitch, so I just had to go on my own knowledge.
In the end I found myself relying on the imprint symbol on the spine of the book more than my passing familiarity with the authors.
Never before had I been so aware of the branding that symbol represents. In general I don’t tend to find house branding that important on the bookstore level. I don’t shelve Random House books together or give Penguin its own bay. There only to publishers in the whole store (Ellora’s and Silhouette/Harlequin series romance) that get that treatment by company mandate, and these are probably the only publishers that my coworkers could easily group by simply looking at the covers. With all the major publishers and imprints running around, it’s easy for a person to develop book blindness, and our customers (for the most part) are even more unaware of imprint signifance.
Does this represent a failure to “brand” on the publisher’s part or simply a failure on our own end to create awareness within our customer base? Do publishers want to brand at all? And as a reader, does this make any difference to you at all, or are you sitting there asking yourself, “What the hell is she talking about?”
Showing posts with label Branding. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Branding. Show all posts
Friday, April 14, 2006
Wednesday, March 15, 2006
Hanging with Chloe and Manolo: Teen Lit, Branding, and the Reading of American Girls
Note: This is a continuation of thoughts expressed on the column, “From Tween to Teen and the Sex In Between,” read that first and the full thoughts left by readers.
Also let’s just define my “I’ll be back with my own thoughts after I get back from work” as “I’ll really be posting tomorrow.” I meant to type this up last night, but I got distracted by making dinner, doing dishes and taking emergency action to save my suddenly dishpan hands. So just bank that “little” definition in your Bookseller Chick dictionary along with planogram (awful, awful word) and other word that I threw out in my quest to explain the life of a chain store bookseller (although this one probably solely applies to me).
Okay? Okay.
JMC brings up an interesting point in her response to yesterday’s post and it really leads into where (I think) I want to go with this:
To me, it appears, she's blaming the publishers and the authors, not the parents, but we'll get to that in a minute.
It was a coworker who brought the Wolf article to my attention on Monday. She—an avid reader of the Gossip Girl and Clique books—asked me what I thought about Wolf’s stance on the subject manner, and when I confessed that I wasn’t up-to-date on my NYT Book Review reading, she summarized. She felt that Wolf over-emphasized the sex and drug aspects of the Gossip Girls books, agreed with her “Mean Girl” stance on the Clique books, but overall felt she missed the point of why these books are popular. “It’s not like these kids can’t see worse on television. I mean, look at The OC.”
Indeed, Gossip Girl et al are representative of the media culture presented to youth on television and movies. The absentee parents, the rampant materialism, the quest to be the most popular: all of these themes are featured regularly on The OC, One Tree Hill, and other teen drama shows. Even Veronica Mars and Gilmore Girls—shows lauded for their writing and acting—use these as plot points. In their defense they don’t seem to invert the parent/child power structure to the extent that Wolf claims the Clique does (or wipe them out all together as in the Gossip Girl books), but it’s there. Veronica’s rich friends have no parental controls at all and drive hummers and porches, Rory gets a Hermes bag from her boyfriend; pop culture references abound.
What I find interesting—and what Wolf leaves out in her article—is that these books (like these TV shows) have a secondary audience. Sure, they are marketed to the 13 and above Young Adult crowd, but they also appeal to adults. Sarah Weinman at GalleyCat refers to them as her “total guilty pleasure complex,” and she is not alone. My coworker is in her early twenties: smart, very literate, but capable of discussing Marc Jacobs in as much detail as she does feminist theory. Her materialistic quest to possess a Chloe bag does not detract from her ability to define herself outside of societal ideals. She just really wants that Chloe bag. Does her desire for a two thousand dollar bag keep her from making an informed decision? No.
Wolf argues that the through the inversion of the core “tradition [that] has been the opposition between the rebel and the popular, often wealthy antiheroine” has created a world where teens “try on adult values and customs as though they were going to wear them forever…offer[ing] the perks of the adult world not as escapist fantasy but in a creepily photorealistic way, just as the book jackets show real girls polished to an unreal gloss.” In the cases of my coworker and Weinman, she would suggest that both realize the unrealistic qualities of the world portrayed whereas teens would view themselves in this warped funhouse mirror and take the reflected image as truth.
This opinion is detrimental in two ways because it both denies a teenager’s ability to make an intelligent and informed decision and implies that parents should just buy other books, placing the onus of the shame and corruption of the teen mind that these books apparently cause on the writers, publishers and booksellers. In blame shifting this responsibility to the sellers and creators, she effectively denies the role of the parent, just as she claims these books do. Perhaps instead of focusing on the books, we should look to see why books about sex and drugs, why publishers feel the need to acknowledge the clothing designers on the cover, and why books on Mean Girl culture and parental absenteeism are so popular.
These are only symptoms of a greater disease. You can’t blame Gossip Girl, the A-List, and the Clique for latch-key children, teen credit debt, and a culture that tries to brand you as soon as you are able to have cognitive recognition of a symbol or word. You can’t blame them for creating an ideal because it was an ideal that put them in this situation. With both parents working sixty to seventy hour work weeks to achieve the American dream, the loss of after school programs and activities, overworked teachers, and the absence of a reliable teen mentorship program for all, it’s no surprise that teens redirect their focus outward and define themselves by what they know: advertising and products.
In some ways, these books go where a lot of parents don’t. They acknowledge that there are teens having sex and doing drugs, even if they glamorize it; they acknowledge that there is a culture of the mean girl—a culture that carries on into adulthood—something that books like Queen Bees and Wannabees and Tripping the Prom Queen are only now admitting to in the feminine world; and they acknowledge the power brands and the teenage buying public, which has been discussed thoroughly in the nonfiction book, Branded: the Buying and Selling of Teenagers. While they exaggerate and gloss over the alternatives and cons to the lifestyle, these books recognize—on some level—issues that teenagers actually deal with on a day to day basis.
It’s not my job as a bookseller to make these buying choices for the parent. Book Nerd points out (in the comments of the last column) “there's no way [that] trying to censor these books is the right answer. We have to give girls some credit for knowing the difference between an accurate representation of their experience and a fantasy.” Not only that, but we have to place the responsibility of teaching this difference on the people that will have the most influence: parents and teachers. As Lady T said in her column, it’s the parents who need to “Take the time and the responsibility to see what your kids may or not be influenced by.” Take the time to read the back of that glossy book before you throw it into your shopping cart or if you see it lying around the house. Maybe even take the time to read the book so that you can have an actual discussion with your child. Maybe then you’ll see that they are capable of distilling the truth from the advertising, or at least you’ll be able to send them on that direction.
Not too long ago I was helping a woman look for a book for her daughter, and she mentioned the girl really wanted to read the Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants series. When I asked the woman how old the girl was she replied that her daughter was twelve.
Because I had read and loved the books, I was aware of certain content, so I mentioned, “Well, one of the characters has sex in the first book, so—”
“They have sex? Never mind then,” the mother snapped, “I don’t want her reading about sex.”
I explained that one character—not all of them—has sex before she is ready, and the books deals with the fallout. I explained that teen sex wasn’t the main thread of the story, it was female friendship. I even mentioned that a lot of adult book clubs had chosen the book to review, so maybe it was something she could read and discuss with her daughter. The mother, however, had made up her mind about those books involving teen sex, and she didn’t have time to read everything her daughter did; she was just there to pick up a book because her child was actually reading!
She eventually came up to the counter with a Clique book.
Your thoughts as a parent? Bookseller? Author? What can be done to help treat the disease, not the symptoms?
Also let’s just define my “I’ll be back with my own thoughts after I get back from work” as “I’ll really be posting tomorrow.” I meant to type this up last night, but I got distracted by making dinner, doing dishes and taking emergency action to save my suddenly dishpan hands. So just bank that “little” definition in your Bookseller Chick dictionary along with planogram (awful, awful word) and other word that I threw out in my quest to explain the life of a chain store bookseller (although this one probably solely applies to me).
Okay? Okay.
JMC brings up an interesting point in her response to yesterday’s post and it really leads into where (I think) I want to go with this:
…I'm not sure who the recipient of the diatribe was supposed to be. The authors for writing what she thinks is materialistic crap? Parents for not paying attention to what their kids are read[ing]? Publishers for putting a product on the market?
To me, it appears, she's blaming the publishers and the authors, not the parents, but we'll get to that in a minute.
It was a coworker who brought the Wolf article to my attention on Monday. She—an avid reader of the Gossip Girl and Clique books—asked me what I thought about Wolf’s stance on the subject manner, and when I confessed that I wasn’t up-to-date on my NYT Book Review reading, she summarized. She felt that Wolf over-emphasized the sex and drug aspects of the Gossip Girls books, agreed with her “Mean Girl” stance on the Clique books, but overall felt she missed the point of why these books are popular. “It’s not like these kids can’t see worse on television. I mean, look at The OC.”
Indeed, Gossip Girl et al are representative of the media culture presented to youth on television and movies. The absentee parents, the rampant materialism, the quest to be the most popular: all of these themes are featured regularly on The OC, One Tree Hill, and other teen drama shows. Even Veronica Mars and Gilmore Girls—shows lauded for their writing and acting—use these as plot points. In their defense they don’t seem to invert the parent/child power structure to the extent that Wolf claims the Clique does (or wipe them out all together as in the Gossip Girl books), but it’s there. Veronica’s rich friends have no parental controls at all and drive hummers and porches, Rory gets a Hermes bag from her boyfriend; pop culture references abound.
What I find interesting—and what Wolf leaves out in her article—is that these books (like these TV shows) have a secondary audience. Sure, they are marketed to the 13 and above Young Adult crowd, but they also appeal to adults. Sarah Weinman at GalleyCat refers to them as her “total guilty pleasure complex,” and she is not alone. My coworker is in her early twenties: smart, very literate, but capable of discussing Marc Jacobs in as much detail as she does feminist theory. Her materialistic quest to possess a Chloe bag does not detract from her ability to define herself outside of societal ideals. She just really wants that Chloe bag. Does her desire for a two thousand dollar bag keep her from making an informed decision? No.
Wolf argues that the through the inversion of the core “tradition [that] has been the opposition between the rebel and the popular, often wealthy antiheroine” has created a world where teens “try on adult values and customs as though they were going to wear them forever…offer[ing] the perks of the adult world not as escapist fantasy but in a creepily photorealistic way, just as the book jackets show real girls polished to an unreal gloss.” In the cases of my coworker and Weinman, she would suggest that both realize the unrealistic qualities of the world portrayed whereas teens would view themselves in this warped funhouse mirror and take the reflected image as truth.
This opinion is detrimental in two ways because it both denies a teenager’s ability to make an intelligent and informed decision and implies that parents should just buy other books, placing the onus of the shame and corruption of the teen mind that these books apparently cause on the writers, publishers and booksellers. In blame shifting this responsibility to the sellers and creators, she effectively denies the role of the parent, just as she claims these books do. Perhaps instead of focusing on the books, we should look to see why books about sex and drugs, why publishers feel the need to acknowledge the clothing designers on the cover, and why books on Mean Girl culture and parental absenteeism are so popular.
These are only symptoms of a greater disease. You can’t blame Gossip Girl, the A-List, and the Clique for latch-key children, teen credit debt, and a culture that tries to brand you as soon as you are able to have cognitive recognition of a symbol or word. You can’t blame them for creating an ideal because it was an ideal that put them in this situation. With both parents working sixty to seventy hour work weeks to achieve the American dream, the loss of after school programs and activities, overworked teachers, and the absence of a reliable teen mentorship program for all, it’s no surprise that teens redirect their focus outward and define themselves by what they know: advertising and products.
In some ways, these books go where a lot of parents don’t. They acknowledge that there are teens having sex and doing drugs, even if they glamorize it; they acknowledge that there is a culture of the mean girl—a culture that carries on into adulthood—something that books like Queen Bees and Wannabees and Tripping the Prom Queen are only now admitting to in the feminine world; and they acknowledge the power brands and the teenage buying public, which has been discussed thoroughly in the nonfiction book, Branded: the Buying and Selling of Teenagers. While they exaggerate and gloss over the alternatives and cons to the lifestyle, these books recognize—on some level—issues that teenagers actually deal with on a day to day basis.
It’s not my job as a bookseller to make these buying choices for the parent. Book Nerd points out (in the comments of the last column) “there's no way [that] trying to censor these books is the right answer. We have to give girls some credit for knowing the difference between an accurate representation of their experience and a fantasy.” Not only that, but we have to place the responsibility of teaching this difference on the people that will have the most influence: parents and teachers. As Lady T said in her column, it’s the parents who need to “Take the time and the responsibility to see what your kids may or not be influenced by.” Take the time to read the back of that glossy book before you throw it into your shopping cart or if you see it lying around the house. Maybe even take the time to read the book so that you can have an actual discussion with your child. Maybe then you’ll see that they are capable of distilling the truth from the advertising, or at least you’ll be able to send them on that direction.
Not too long ago I was helping a woman look for a book for her daughter, and she mentioned the girl really wanted to read the Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants series. When I asked the woman how old the girl was she replied that her daughter was twelve.
Because I had read and loved the books, I was aware of certain content, so I mentioned, “Well, one of the characters has sex in the first book, so—”
“They have sex? Never mind then,” the mother snapped, “I don’t want her reading about sex.”
I explained that one character—not all of them—has sex before she is ready, and the books deals with the fallout. I explained that teen sex wasn’t the main thread of the story, it was female friendship. I even mentioned that a lot of adult book clubs had chosen the book to review, so maybe it was something she could read and discuss with her daughter. The mother, however, had made up her mind about those books involving teen sex, and she didn’t have time to read everything her daughter did; she was just there to pick up a book because her child was actually reading!
She eventually came up to the counter with a Clique book.
***
Your thoughts as a parent? Bookseller? Author? What can be done to help treat the disease, not the symptoms?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)